The line of Elros

The Line of Elros

by David Seuferer
davids1690@aol.com


                                  The Line of Elros,
                           Kings of Numenor, Arnor, Gondor,
                                         and
                              Chieftains of the Dunedain

                                    Earendil = Elwing
                                            |
                                    |---------------|
                                   Elros          Elrond
                               Tar-Minyatur
                             532FA-32SA-442SA
                                    |
             |------------------|-----------|-----------|
     Vardamir Noliman (1)   Tindomiel   Manwendil   Atanalcar
    61SA-442SA-443SA-471SA      d.          :           :
             |
      |--------------|----------|---------------------------------------|
Tar-Amandil(2)   Vardilme   Aulendil                                Nolondil
192-443-590-603      d.         :                                       |
      |                                                                 |
      |-------------------------------|--------|       |--------|-------|
Tar-Elendil                        Earendur  Mairen Yavien Oromendil Axantur
350-590-740-751                        |       d.      d.               |
     |                                 |                                |
     |---------------|-----|           |           |--------|-----------|
Silmarien=Elatan  Isilme   |           Caliondo  Lindisse  Ardamir  Cemendur
    d.   |of Andunie    d. |                  |     d.       :          |
         |        Tar-Meneldur(3)=Almarian(4) |                         |
    |----|       543-740-883-942 |            |--|                      |
    |           |--------------------|----|      |         |------------|
    |     Tar-Aldarion(5)=Erendis(6) | Almiel Malantur   Irilde     Hallatan
    |   700-883-1075-1098|           |           :         d.          of
Valandil                 |       Ailinel=Orchaldor(7)            Hyarastorni
Lord of Andunie     |----|          d.  |                               |
    :               |                   |        |----------------------|
    :       Tar-Ancalime(8)=Hallacar Soronto  Nessamie  Tar-Ancalime=Hallacar
    :    873-1075-1280-1285|                     d.
    :  (First Ruling Queen)|
    :                      |
    :                 Tar-Anarion
    :             1003-1280-1334-1404
    :                      |
    :            |-----|--------------|
    :            ?     ?         Tar-Surion(9)
    :            d.    d.     1174-1384-1556-1574
    :                                 |
    :                          |--------------|
    :                   Tar-Telperien(10)   Isilmo
    :                    1320-1556-1731       |
    :                 (Second Ruling Queen)   |
    :                                         |
    :                                   Tar-Minastir(11)
    :                                  1474-1731-1863-1873
    :                                         |
    :                                  Tar-Ciryatan(12)
    :                                 1634-1869-2029-2035
    :                                         |
    :                                  Tar-Atanamir The Great(13)
    :                                 1800-2029-2251
    :                                         |
    :                                  |-------------|
    :                            Tar-Ancalimon(14)   ?
    :                           1886-2251-2386       |
    :                                  |             |
    :                            Tar-Telemmaite(15)  ?
    :                            2136-2386-2526      |
    :                                  |             |
    :                            Tar-Vanimelde(16)=Herucalmo(Tar-Anducal)
    :                            2277-2526-2637   |         2286-2637-2657
    :                         (Third Ruling Queen)|
    :                                             |
    :                                        Tar-Alcarin
    :                                      2406-2657-2737
    :                                             |
    :                                        Tar-Calmacil(Ar-Belyagar)(17)
    :                                       2516-2737-2825
    :                                             |
    --------|                          |------------------------|
            :                    Tar-Ardamin(Ar-Abattarik)  Gimilzagar
            :                     2618-2825-2899            born in 2630
            :                          |                        |
            :                Ar-Adunakhor(Tar-Herunumen)(18)    ?
            :               2709-2899-2962                      |
            :                      |                            |
            ?                Ar-Zinrathon(Tar-Hostamir)         ?
            |               2788-2962-3033                      |
    |--------------|               |                            |
Earendur(19)  ?=Lindorie     Ar-Sakalthor(Tar-Falassion)        ?=Lindorie
15th Lord of                2876-3033-3102                       |(House of
  Andunie                          |                             |  Andunie)
    |                              |                             |
    ?                         Ar-Gimilzor(Tar-Telemnar)(20)=Inzilbeth
    |                        2960-3102-3177                |
    |                               |----------------------------|
 Numendil                     Tar-Palantir(Ar-Inziladun)(21)  Gimilkhad
    |                        3035-3177-3255                   3044-3243
    |                               |                            |
 Amandil(23)            Tar-Miriel(Ar-Zimraphel)=Ar-Pharazon(Tar-Celion)(22)
death in 3316?              3319                 3118-3255-3319
    |
 Elendil The Tall(24)
 death in 3441 SA
    |
    |-------------------------|
                              |
                     |------------------------|
                  Isildur(48)              Anarion
                 3209 SA-2 TA          death in 3440 SA
                     |                        |
    |-----------|-------|--------|          |--|--|------|
  Elendur     Aratan  Ciryon  Valandil      ?  ?  ?  Meneldil(25)
3299 SA-2 TA   2 TA    2 TA    249 TA               3318 SA-158 TA
                                 |                       |
                              Eldacar                Cemendur
                               399 TA                 238 TA
                                 |                       |
                              Arantar                Earendil
                               435 TA                 324 TA
                                 |                       |
                              Tarcil                  Anardil
                                515                     411
                                 |                       |
                              Tarondor                Ostoher(26)
                                602                     492
                                 |                       |
                              Valandur           Romendacil I (Tarostar)(27)
                                652                     541
                                 |                       |
                              Elendur                Turambar(28)
                                777                     667
                                 |                       |
                              Earendur(49)           Atanatar I
                                861                     748
                                 |                       |
              |------------|------------|                |
           Amlaith         ?(50)        ?(50)        Siriondil
         of Arthedain  of Rhudaur  of Cardolan          830
             946                                         |
              |                              |-------------------|
              |    Queen Beruthiel = Tarannon Falastur(29)   Tarciryan
              |         (29A)            (Ship King)             |
              |                      (First Childless King)      |
              |                             913                  |
              |                                               Earnil I (30)
              |                                              (Ship King)
              |                                                 936
              |                                                  |
            Beleg                                            Ciryandil(31)
             1026                                             (Ship King)
              |                                                 1015
              |                                                  |
            Mallor                                        Hyarmendacil I(32)
             1110                                           (Ciryaher)
              |                                             (Ship King)
              |                                                1149
              |                                                  |
              |                                       Atanatar II(33)
              |                                       (Alcarin The Glorious)
          Celepharn                                        1226
             1191                                            |
              |                                  |------------------|
              |                          Narmacil I(34)          Calmacil
          Celebrindor                (Second Childless King)       1304
             1272                            1294                   |
              |                       |-------------------------------|
           Malvegil(51)            Minalcor (Romendacil II)(35)  Calimehtar
             1349                  (Regent 1240-1304)                 |
              |                      1366                             |
           Argeleb I(52)              |                               |
             1356                  Valacar(36)=Vidumavi(37)           ?
              |                      1432     |                       |
           Arveleg I(53)            Eldacar(Vinitharya)(38)     Castamir(39)
             1409                         1255-1490       (Captain of Ships)
              |                               |                 (The Usuper)
              |                |--------|---------|                   |
           Araphor(54)     Ornendil  Aldamir  Minardil(40)            ?
             1589             1437?   1540      1634                  |
              |                         |         |                   |
              |                 |--------     |-------------|         |
          Argeleb II(55)  Hyarmendacil II  Telemnar(41)  Minastan     ?
            1670            (Vinyarian)      1636           |         |
              |                1621    |------|       |-----|   |-----|
              |                        |              |         |
              |                        |       |------|         |
              |                    |-----|     |          |-----------|
           Arvegil                 ?     ?  Tarondor  Angamaite  Sangahyando
            1743                 1636  1636   1798
              |                                |
           Arveleg II                   Telumehtar Umbardacil(42)
             1813                             1850
              |                                |
              |                    |-----------------------------|
           Araval              Narmacil II(43)                Arciryas
            1891                 1856                            |
              |                    |                             |
          Araphant             Calimehtar(44)                Calimmacil
            1964                  1936                           |
              |                    |                             |
              |              |----------------------|            |
              |           Ondoher(45)               ?        Siriondil
              |             1944                    d.           |
   |----------|              |                      |            |
   |                    |----|---|                  |            |
Arvedui(56)=Firiel    Artamir | Firiel=Arvedui   Minohtar  Earnil II(46)
(Last King)|(Daughter  1944   |       (Last King)  1944         2043
  1974     |    of         Faramir                 (45A)         |
           | Ondoher)       1944                                 |
           |----|                                              Earnur(47)
                |                                               2050
              |-------------|
           Aranarth         ?
             2106
              |
        |-----------|
     Arahael(57)    ?
      2177
        |
     Aranuir
       2247
        |
      Aravir
       2319
        |
     Aragorn I(58)
       2327
        |
     Araglas
       2455
        |
     Arahad I(59)
       2543
        |
     Aragost
       2588
        |
     Aravorn
       2654
        |
     Arahad II
      2719
        |
     Arassuil(60)
       2784
        |
     Arathorn I
       2848
        |
     Argonui
      2912
        |
     Arador(61)    Dirhael(62)=Ivorwen
       2930                   |
        |                     |
     Arathorn II(63)   =   Gilraen the Fair
                       |
                    Aragorn II(64)   =   Arwen
                 (Elessar Tel-Contar)|(Daughter of Elrond)
                 2931 TA-120 4th Age |
                             |-------|-------|
                          Eldarion   ?       ?
                                     d.      d.

                                                 d. = daughter
                                                 :  = Had a male heir at the
                                                      time of the change in
                                                      the succession law.
                                            4 dates = birth, start of reign,
                                                      end of reign, death
                                            3 dates = birth, start of reign,
                                                      death
                                            2 dates = birth, death
                                                 FA = First Age
                                                 SA = Second Age
                                                 TA = Third Age

Note 1: He was called Noliman because of his love of ancient lore.  Upon
	recieving the Sceptre he passed it on to his son, but is counted as
	having ruled one year.  It remained the custom	until Tar-Atanamir
	that the king should yield the sceptre	before his death.  The kings
	died of free will while yet in	the vigor of mind.{UT 213-214}.

Note 2: He was also called Parmaite, for with his own hand he made many
	books and legends of the lore gathered by his grandfather.
	Numenoreans first come back to Middle-Earth.{UT 214}

Note 3: His 'right name' was Irimon; he took his title Meneldur from his
	love of star-lore.  He retired the Sceptre earlier than usual,
	because of Gil-Galad's worries about the rising of an Evil power in
	the East, and he thought his son would be better suited to handle
	the coming crisis.{UT 192-196}.

Note 4: She was the daughter of Veantur, Captain of Ships.{UT 165}

Note 5: His birth name was Anardil.  He became known as Aldarin
	because of his planting of great forests to furnish timber for the
	shipyards.  He was a friend and counclor to Gil-Galad.  He altered
	the succession law so that his daughter could take the Sceptre.  His
	marrage to Erendis was	stormy and not a very happy one.{UT 165-198,
	214-215}

Note 6: Her mother was Nuneth and her father was Bregar of the House of
	Beor.  She was descended from Bereth, who was the sister of Baragund
	and Belegund.{UT 169,208}

Note 7: Son of Hatholdir, descendent of the House of Hador.{UT 165}

Note 8: She was declared King's Heir at the age of 19.  The traditional age
	was 100.  After Tar-Aldarion's death she neglected all of his
	policies and sent no more aid to Gil-Galad.  Her marrage to Hallacar
	was also an unhappy one.{UT 169, 201, 204, 205}

Note 9: His sisters refused the Sceptre.{UT 215}

Note 10: She would not wed.{UT 215}

Note 11: He took this name because he built a high tower on the hill of
	 Oromet, near Andunie and the west shore.  He sent a great
 	 fleet to the aid of Gil-Galad in the first wars with Sauron.{UT 216}

Note 12: He was a greedy man and built a great royal fleet.  His servants
	 oppressed the men of Middle-Earth.  It is said that he forced his
	 father to give up the Sceptre before he wanted to.{UT 216}

Note 13: He was a proud and greedy man like his father.  He exacted a heavy
	 tribute from the men on the coasts of Middle-Earth.  In his heart he
	 turned against the Valar and Eldar.  He was also called 'The
	 Unwilling' because he was the first King to refuse to lay down his
	 life or to renounce the Sceptre.  He lived until death took him by
	 force in sinility.{UT 216}

Note 14: The rift between The King's Men and those who still maintained
	 friendship with the Eldar grew wider.  Many of The King's Men
	 stopped using the Elven-tongue and no longer taught it to their
	 children.{UT 216,217}

Note 15: This king was so named because of his love of silver and he
	 commanded his servants to seek for mithril.{UT 217}

Note 16: She gave little heed to ruling, loving rather music and dance.  The
	 real power was wielded by her younger husband.  On her death
	 Herucalmo took the Sceptre withholding it from his son.{UT 217}

Note 17: The King's name was first spoken in Adunic under his rule.  He
	 took this name, because in his youth he was a great Captain and won
	 many lands along the coasts of Middle-Earth.  Thus he kindled the
	 hatred of Sauron.{UT 217}

Note 18: First King to take the Sceptre with an Andunic name.  The
	 elven-tongues were no longer used or permitted to be taught.{UT 218}

Note 19: {UT 219, SIL 267}

Note 20: He was the greatest of the enemies of the Faithful that had yet
	 risen.  He forbade the use of Eldarin tongues and would not permit
	 any of the Eldar to come to the land and he punished those who
	 welcomed them.  He revered nothing and never went to the Hallow of
	 Eru.{UT 218}

Note 21: He repented the acts of the King's before him and wished to be
	 friends with the Eldar and The Lords of the West.  He took his name
	 because he was far-sighted both in eyes and in mind and even his
	 enemies feared his words as those of a true-seer.  He visited the
	 Hallow of Eru at the proper times.  He prophesied that when the
	 White Tree died the line of the Kings also would perish.{UT 218,219}

Note 22: He usurped the thrown from Miriel and married her against the law
	 of Numenor.  He was said to be the mightiest of the Kings of
	 Numenor.  He captured Sauron and brought him to Numenor as a
	 hostage.  He soon started to listen to the lies of Sauron and
	 brought about the destruction of Numenor.{UT 219, SIL 268-278}

Note 23: He set sail for Valinor to beg the Valar for mercy and he was never
	 seen again.{SIL 274}

Note 24: He fled to Middle-Earth at the destruction of Numenor with nine
	 ships.  Four of the ships were for his Household, three for Isildur,
	 and two for Anarion.  Elendil's ships were blown north in the storms
	 of Numenor's destruction where he founded the kingdom of Arnor.
	 Isildur and Anarion's ships were blown south and they founded the
	 kingdom of Gondor.{SIL 278}

Note 25: He was a man of courtesy, but far-seeing, and he did not reveal his
	 thoughts.  He was the fourth child of Anarion and the last man born
	 in Numenor.{UT 278}

Note 26: He rebuilt Minas Anor and Gondor was first attacked by wild men
	 from the East.{LOTR III 403}

Note 27: Took the name Romendacil 'East-victor' when he defeated and drove
	 out the Easterlings during his fathers reign.  He was slain in
	 battle with new hordes of Easterlings.{LOTR III 403}

Note 28: He avenged his father's death against the Easterlings and won large
	 territories in the East.{LOTR III 403}

Note 29: His name Falastur means 'Lord of the Coasts'.  He built large
	 navies and extended Gondor's power along the coasts west and south
	 of the Mouths of Anduin.{LOTR III 403}

Note 29A: She was a nefarious, solitary, and loveless wife.  She hated the
          sounds and smells of the sea, all making, all colors and elaborate
          adornment, wearing only black and silver and living in bare chambers.
          She had nine black cats and one white, her slaves, with whom she
          conversed, or read their memories, setting them to discover all the
          dark secrets of Gondor, so that she knew those things 'that men wish
          most to keep hidden', setting the white cat to spy upon the black,
          and tormenting them.  Her name was erased from the Book of the Kings,
          and that King Tarannon had her set on a ship alone with her cats and
          set adrift on the sea before a north wind.  The ship was last seen
          flying past Umbar under a sickle moon, with a cat at the masthead and
          another as a figure-head on the prow.{UT 407}

Note 30: He regained the Haven of Pelargir and built a great navy.  He laid
	 seige to Umbar and took it in 933 SA.  In 936 he and many ships were
	 lost in a great storm off of Umbar.{LOTR III 403}

Note 31: He continued the building of ships.  The men of the Harad, led by
	 the lords that were driven out of Umbar, came up with a great force
	 and attacked Umbar and Ciryandil fell in battle in Haradwaith.{LOTR
	 III 403}

Note 32: He bided his time and gathered a strong army and he came down from
	 the north by sea and by land, and crossing the River Harrien his
	 armies utterly defeated the Men of the Harad in 1050  SA.  Gondor
	 now reaches the height of its power.  Hyarmendacil means 'South
	 Victor'.{LOTR III 403-404}

Note 33: He loved ease and did nothing to maintain the power he inherited,
	 and his two sons were of like mind.{LOTR III 404}

Note 34: Easterling attacks start again.{LOTR III 404}

Note 35: In 1240 SA he was made regent by Narmacil I to rid himself of all
	 cares.  He was a man of grear vigor.  His chief concern was with the
	 Northmen.  In 1248 SA he led a great force, and between the
	 Rhovanion and the Inland Sea he defeated a large army of Easterlings
	 an destroyed all their camps and settlements east of the Sea.  He
	 then took the name of Romendacil.  He built the pillars of the
	 Argonath at the entrance to Nen Hithoel.{LOTR III 404-405}

Note 36: In 1250 SA he was sent to the King of Rhovanin, Vidugavia, as an
	 ambassador.  In his time the first disaster of Gondor began, the
	 Kin-strife.{LOTR III 405}

Note 37: She was the daughter of Vidugavia, King of the Rhovanin.{LOTR III
	 405}

Note 38: He was supported by the Northmen and the Dunadain of northern
	 Gondor.  He was deposed in 1437 SA and restored in 1447 SA.  The
	 Stone in the Tower of the Stone in Osgiliath was lost in the waters
	 of Anduin when he was besieged there.  In a battle in Lebennin, at
	 the crossings of Erui, Eldacar slew Castamir in battle.  Castamir's
	 followers fled to Umbar.  Gondor and Umbar were at war for many live
	 times.{LOTR III 405-406}

Note 39: He was supported by men of the coasts and the great havens of
	 Pelargir and Umbar.  Castamir was said to have been a cruel,
	 haughty, and ungenerous man.{LOTR III 406}

Note 40: He was slain at Pelargir in a battle with the Corsairs of Umbar who
	 were led by Angamaite and Sangahyundo, the great-grandsons of
	 Castamir.{LOTR III 407}

Note 41: The second disaster of Gondor was the plague that came with dark
	 winds out of the East.  Telemnar and his children died in the
	 plague.  For weariness and fewness of men because of the plague the
	 watch on Mordor ceased.{LOTR III 407, 408}

Note 42: In 1810 TA he gathered his forces and took Umbar by storm.  In that
	 war the last descendents of Castamir perished and Umbar was Gondors
	 again.{LOTR III 408}

Note 43: The third disaster of Gondor was the invasion of the Wainriders.
	 Narmacil II was killed in battle with the Wainriders beyond Anduin.
	 Gondor's frontiers for a time were witdrawn to the Anduin and Emyn
	 Muil.  The Ring-Wraiths re-enter Mordor.{LOTR III 408-409}

Note 44: In 1899 TA he had a great victory versus the Wainriders upon
	 Dagorlad.{LOTR III 409}

Note 45: He and his sons were killed in battle with the Wainriders north of
	 Morannon.{LOTR III 409}

Note 45A: He was King Ondoher's sister-son.  He was in command of the rearguard
          defense.  But the Wainriders poured relentlessly into Ithilien and
          late on the thirteenth day of Cermie they overwhelmed Minohtar, who
          was slain by an arrow.  His men carried him out of the fray, and all
          that remained of the rearguard fled southwards to find Commander
          Adrahil.{UT 294}

Note 46: He was Captain of the Southern Army and he defeated Harad at the
	 River Poros and then he turned north and gathered to him the
	 reinments of the defeated Northern Army and routed the Wainriders.
	 He was given the crown in 1945 TA.  He sent aid to King Arvedui but
	 it arrived to late.{LOTR III 409}

Note 47: He was like his father in valour, but not in wisdom.  He would take
	 no wife, for his only pleasure was in fighting.  He at last accepted
	 the Witch-King's challenge to single combat and he went to Minas
	 Morgul with a small escort of knights and was never seen again.  It
	 is believed that he died under torture.  He was the last king of
	 Gondor until the return of Aragorn II in The War of the Ring.{LOTR
	 III 413}

Note 48: His three oldest sons were slain at the disaaster at Gladden
	 Fields.  Isildur is slain and loses the One Ring in the Anduin.{UT
	 269-275}

Note 49: After his reign the kings no longer take names in High-Elven
	 form.{LOTR III 394}

Note 50: Because of dessension among Earendur's sons the kingdom was split
	 into three kingdoms.  The lines of Isildur soon perished in Cardolan
	 and Rhudaur.  Rhudaur and Cardolan fought for the possesion of Amon
	 Sul, because the Tower of Amon Sul held the Cheif Palantir of the
	 North and the other two were in the keeping of Arthedain.{LOTR III
	 394, 396, 397}

Note 51: At this time the kingdom of Angmar first arose.{LOTR III 397}

Note 52: Since there were no descendents of Isuldur left in Cardolan and
	 Rhudaur Argeleb I claimed kingship of all of Arnor once more.  In
	 token of this the kings took names prefixed with Ar-.  This claim
	 was resisted in Rhudaur because power had been claimed by an evil
	 lord of the Hillmen, who was secretly in league with Angmar.
	 Argeleb I fortified the Weather Hills.  He was slain in battle with
	 Rhudaur and Angmar.{LOTR III 394,397}

Note 53: With help from Cardolan and Lindon he drove back his enemies from
	 the Weather Hills.  A great force came out of Angmar in 1409 TA and
	 entered Cardolan and Weather Top was surrounded.  Arveleg I was
	 slain in battle and The Tower of Amon Sul was burned and razed but
	 the Palantir was saved and carried to Fornost.{LOTR III 397}

Note 54: He was not full grown but with the help of Cirdan he repelled the
	 enemy from Fornost and the North Downs.  The power of Angmar was
	 checked for a time by the Elvenfolk out of Lindon, Rivendell and
	 Lorien.{LOTR III 397,398}

Note 55: The Pleague came into Eriador and most people of Cardolan perished,
	 especially in Minhiriath.  The Dunedain of Cardolan ended and evil
	 spirits came out of Angmar and Rhudaur and entered into the deserted
	 mounds and dwelt there.{LOTR III 398}

Note 56: Angmar rose agian and attacked Arthedain in 1974 TA and he captured
	 Fornost.  Arvedui took shelter with the Lossoth, the snowmen of
	 Forochel.  When Cirdan heard this he sent a ship to look for him.
	 Before Arvedui left he gave the Ring of Barahir to the Chief of the
	 Lossoth as thanks (the Dunadain later paid a ransome to get the ring
	 back).  As he sailed away a great storm wind arose and crushed his
	 ship against the ice.  The stones of Annuminas and Amon Sul were
	 also lost when Arvedui's ship sank.  After Arvedui the North Kingdom
	 ended.  When the North Kingdom ended the Dunadain pasted into the
	 shadows and became a secret and wandering people, and thier deeds
	 and labors were seldom sung or recorded.{LOTR 399,400,401}

Note 57: He was fostered in Imaldris as were all following sons.{LOTR 401}

Note 58: He was slain by wolves.{LOTR III 401}

Note 59: In 2509 TA the orcs of the Misty Mountains reveal themselves.{LOTR
	 III 401}

Note 60: The orcs of the Misty Mountains begin to ravage the lands and the
	 Dunadain with the help of the sons of Elrond fight them.{LOTR III
	 402}

Note 61: He was slain in the Coldfells north of Rivendell by hill-trolls.
	 {LOTR III 420}

Note 62: He was a descendent of Aranarth.{LOTR III 420}

Note 63: He went riding with the sons of Elrond against the orcs and was
	 slain when an orc-arrow pierced his eye.{LOTR III 420}

Note 64: He lived through many adventures and trials and during the War of
	 the Ring he returned to Gondor and claimed the crown of both Gondor
	 and Arnor.[The Lord of the Rings]

Author's Note:  There are several descripencies in the above geneology and
		the Tale of Years in Appendix A in The Lord of the Rings.
 		The differencies are as follows:
		1) The date for the aid to Gil-Galad by Tar-Minastir is
		   stated as 1700 SA in the Tale of Years, but in Unfinished
		   Tales Tar-Minastir doesn't start his reign until 1731 SA.
		   Christopher Tolkien could not account for the
			  discrepancy.{UT 221,222}
		2) Christopher Tolkien believes that the date for the death
		   of Tar-Atanamir in the Tale of Years is in error.{UT 222}
		3) Christopher Tolkien also believes that Tar-Arlamin was
		   accidently left out of the Tale of Years.{UT 222}
		4) Tar-Palantir's dates are different, 3175 SA changed to
		   3177 SA, and Christopher Tolkien didn't know why the dates
		   were changed.{UT 223}


David Seuferer
davids1690@aol.com